Ralph Goodale's Report

A weekly commentary by the Member of Parliament for Wascana


Commentary for December 23, 2011

MR. HARPER PUTS JAILS AHEAD OF HEALTHCARE

This year is ending with some odd contradictions.

The Harper government says it doesn’t want to risk European-like debt problems, so it will curtail future federal funding for healthcare, and Canadians will just have to settle for a patchwork of provincial differences and deficiencies across the country.

But strangely, Mr. Harper has more than enough money to spend billions on bigger jails.  He has more than enough money to spend additional billions on over-priced, uncompetitive fighter-jets.

He has more than enough money for expensive government advertising, unlimited political consultants, the most costly Cabinet in history (including his high-flying, high-living Defense Minister), and 30 more MPs to be added to the House of Commons (costing $100 million more per Parliament).

But healthcare is less important and must be cut back?  Really?

The Harper government is also contradictory on job creation.  They claim jobs are their Number One priority.  Yet, this coming Sunday, the Conservatives will increase job-killing EI payroll taxes by $600 million, hitting every employee and employer in the country – small businesses especially.

Now is the wrong time to hike payroll taxes.  Canada’s unemployment rate is rising.  The quality of available jobs is falling.  Even here in buoyant Saskatchewan, we lost 4,200 jobs last month and the unemployment rate jumped by a full percentage point.

A third contradiction – a truly mean-spirited one – is the way the Harper government designs its “tax credits”.

In this year’s budget, the Conservatives boasted about “tax credits” for volunteer fire-fighters, homecare givers and families enrolling their children in arts programs.  But there’s a catch.  You have to earn a minimum level of income before you qualify.  Below that level, you get nothing.

So why does this government deliberately discriminate against lower-income fire-fighters, homecare givers and families?

In the eyes of Conservatives, why are less wealthy Canadians less worthy of help?

Commentary Archive

May 7, 2012 - GOVERNMENT MANDATE IS A MODEST ONE

May 1, 2012 - PBO DEMOLISHES GOVERNMENT ON PENSIONS & WAR-PLANES

April 30, 2012 - FEDERAL RAIL SERVICE REVIEW - EXPECT A DISAPPOINTING OUTCOME

April 27, 2012 - CATTLEMEN FOCUS ON SERIOUS ISSUES

April 23, 2012 - SCRUTINIZE GLENCORE - OTHER INVESTORS – STANDBY

April 17, 2012 - THE CANADIAN CHARTER OF RIGHTS AND FREEDOMS – AT 30!

April 16, 2012 - WHATS INCLUDED IN MR. HARPERS ACQUISITION COST

April 11, 2012 - 2012 – A YEAR OF GREAT ANNIVERSARIES

April 9, 2012 - THREE POWERFUL ISSUES WITH LEGS

April 4, 2012 - NEW AUDITOR-GENERAL EXPOSES DISHONESTY ABOUT JETS